Highlights of the 10/20/26 Tompkins County Legislature meeting
Published on October 26, 2026
Watch Part 1 and Part 2 of the meeting recording on YouTube
Jump to specific agenda item discussions – click ‘Media’ on the Meeting Portal
Topics included:
- Legislature calls for independent review of District Attorney's Office
- Sheriff presents proposal for a Special Victims Unit
- Legislature advances amendments to the proposed 2027 county budget
- Legislature approves expanded property tax exemptions for older adults and residents with disabilities
- Tourism capital grants awarded to support local attractions
- Legislature recognizes the contributions of local election workers
Legislature calls for independent review of District Attorney's Office
The legislature voted 14-2 to approve a resolution authorizing an independent, comprehensive review of the Tompkins County District Attorney's Office and calling for policy changes related to the handling of sexual assault cases and support for victims. Legislators Shurtleff (R-Groton, Dryden) and Hunt (D-Ithaca Town) voted against the resolution.
Legislator Weiser (D-Caroline, Danby), who introduced the resolution, said the review was intended to examine how cases have been handled, identify potential shortcomings and recommend improvements. She emphasized that the legislature was not being asked to determine whether a crime occurred or to make decisions about a pending prosecution.
Legislators debated the scope and wording of the resolution, including whether it should explicitly reference concerns arising from a recent sexual assault case involving Cornell University. Some members argued that acknowledging the circumstances prompting the resolution was necessary for accountability, while others expressed concern about commenting on a pending legal matter or creating confusion about the purpose of the review.
During the discussion, legislators revised the resolution's title to describe an independent, comprehensive review, reflecting the intent to examine office practices more broadly.
District Attorney Matthew Van Houten participated in the discussion and expressed willingness to cooperate with a review of his office's practices. He also answered questions about the investigative and prosecutorial process, including how prosecutors work with investigators and prepare witnesses.
Sheriff presents proposal for a Special Victims Unit
Tompkins County Sheriff Derek Osborne presented a proposal to establish a countywide Special Victims Unit (SVU) within the Sheriff's Office to strengthen investigations involving sexual assault, child abuse, and other sensitive crimes.
The proposed unit would bring together specially trained investigators and professionals to improve coordination, evidence collection, case preparation, and support for victims. The staffing model includes a dedicated lieutenant, five criminal investigators, and an investigator specializing in evidence and forensic services. The proposal also envisions a dedicated prosecutor from the District Attorney's Office and a victim advocate from the Advocacy Center of Tompkins County working closely with the unit.
Osborne explained that law enforcement agencies throughout the county have capable investigators, but smaller departments may not have personnel who can focus exclusively on complex special victims cases. The proposed model would allow participating agencies to collaborate through formal agreements while maintaining their respective responsibilities.
The presentation was intended to begin consideration of the proposal, not to seek immediate approval of the unit. Osborne stressed the importance of specialized training, consistent investigative practices, trauma-informed approaches, and coordination among law enforcement, prosecutors, and victim advocates.
Read the Sheriff’s full statement
Read the 10/21/26 joint press release
Legislature advances amendments to the proposed 2027 Tentative County Budget
The legislature unanimously approved a package of amendments to the 2027 Tentative Budget and 2027-2031 Capital Program, advancing the amended spending plan to the next stage of the budget process.
Budget, Capital and Personnel Committee Chair Dawson (D-Lansing, Ithaca Town) introduced the resolution following the legislature's budget deliberations. The amended tentative budget includes a proposed 7.69% property tax levy increase which is above the tax cap.
Legislators clarified that the October 20 vote was not final adoption of the 2027 Budget. The amended Tentative Budget will be subject to a public hearing on October 27 and further consideration before a final adoption vote. Additional amendments may still be proposed. Further amendments were introduced during the meeting.
Recycling and waste reduction funding discussion postponed
Legislator Brown (R-Newfield, Enfield) proposed increasing funding for recycling and materials management initiatives by $500,000 in 2027, supported by changes to the county's annual solid waste fee.
The proposal generated an extended discussion about reducing waste sent to landfills, expanding reuse opportunities, the cost of new initiatives and the impact of additional fees on residents. Legislators also discussed the need to identify specific services and projects that would be supported by the proposed revenue. Some members supported making a larger investment in waste reduction, while others questioned whether the funding proposal was sufficiently developed for inclusion in the budget.
The legislature voted 12-4 to postpone consideration of the amendment until November 17, allowing more time to clarify the proposed fee structure and intended uses of the funding.
Legislature rescinds additional beautification funding
The legislature unanimously approved an amendment introduced by Legislator Hubbard (D-Ithaca City, Town), rescinding a previously approved $50,000 increase for beautification projects, returning the funding to its original $150,000 level. Hubbard initially proposed separating the existing beautification program from potential improvements to county buildings, but withdrew that proposal following discussion. Legislators agreed that the existing program should continue without disruption, while potential improvements to county properties could be considered separately after further planning.
Proposed restoration of GED program funding fails
Legislator Weiser (D-Caroline, Danby) introduced an amendment seeking to restore funding for a GED educational program that had been removed from the Probation Department's proposed budget.
Weiser spoke about the value of educational opportunities for individuals involved in the criminal justice system and the potential benefits of helping participants obtain a high school equivalency diploma. During the discussion, legislators considered the program's outcomes, costs, and whether additional funding would necessarily restore the same program or could be directed toward other educational services. The amendment failed 5-11.
Legislature approves expanded property tax exemptions for older adults and residents with disabilities
Following a public hearing at which no members of the public spoke, the legislature unanimously adopted Local Law No. F of 2026, amending the county's authorized property tax exemptions for certain older adults and residents with disabilities under Sections 467 and 459-c of New York State Real Property Tax Law.
Tompkins County Director of Assessment Jay Franklin explained that the local law establishes an income threshold of $40,400 for a 50% exemption, with additional exemption levels determined according to the sliding scale established in state law. The action updates the county's exemption provisions to provide property tax relief for qualifying residents.
Tourism capital grants awarded
The legislature unanimously approved the award of approximately $232,000 in 2026 tourism capital grants, supporting improvements to facilities and attractions that serve visitors and county residents.
Projects discussed included improvements involving the Finger Lakes Land Trust, Paleontological Research Institution, Sciencenter, Cinemapolis, and accessibility improvements in the Town of Dryden. The grants support capital planning and facility improvements intended to strengthen tourism assets and enhance the quality of life for residents. The legislature also unanimously approved the associated environmental review determination.
Public hearings
The legislature held two public hearings concerning acceptance of a Monroe balancing test analysis related to a county shelter in the Town of Ithaca and the proposed Local Law No. F of 2026. No members of the public spoke.
A public hearing on the Tentative 2027 Budget is scheduled for October 27. Watch the livestream and/or provide public comment.
County Infrastructure Grant Program
New York State has opened a new round of funding through the County Infrastructure Grant Program. Tompkins County can submit one infrastructure project for the development of at least 10 housing units for up to $1.5 million in support. Tompkins County is accepting expressions of interest from anyone with a potential infrastructure project by Monday, November 16. To learn more and apply, visit the Housing web page.
Proclamation
Legislature Chair Black (D-Ithaca Town) presented a proclamation recognizing October 20 as a day to celebrate the efforts of local election workers and partners. The proclamation acknowledged the work of election officials, poll workers, volunteers, and public safety partners in administering secure, accurate, and accessible elections.
How to stay engaged